Week 6 - CRIME SCENE ROUND 2

[Rellim]

It seems that Hermes could have been murdered as early as hour 3. It appears the murderer killed him then escaped through the window to outside.

So far Tryina and Mister M were seen on the water slide after the time period in which Hermes was last seen. However it seems like Mister M was outside the entire time before being on the slide.

Tryina however is spotted on the slide after starting out in the house but was so far not spotted going outside by anyone... grumpy

[Deleted]

im pretty confident now hat its bandit. in his hour 3 bandit sees hermes ehading to the hallway, but it specifically says the dreamatorium in an earlier post (pandoras i think) (no, wait, it was pens). and as betsy says, it looks like hermes was killed in hour 3. grumpy

[Pen]

The hallway leads to the dreamatorium, though. grumpy

[Deleted]

ah, okay, that makes sense grumpy

[Rellim]

I'm gonna officially accuse Tryina, who hasn't posted anything yet. grumpy

[Deleted]

Here is mine! Sorry, I was late.

Jul 28, 2014 15:05:57 GMT Big Anka said:

Body: Plenty of blood, also a fatal knife wound
Dreams: You investigate the dreamatorium log, it turns out Hermes was dreaming up the next chapter in a collaborative fiction, but now it will never be finished.
Cupboard: You notice a knife missing
Cocktail Bar: you sit at the bar and relax, you have a clear view of the house, and a lovely drink in your hand

I'll find a way to post the hour thing soon because I'm using a cellphone and it's hard to copy/paste. grumpy

[BigSam]

To give you time to go over the clues and talk about this, this task will end at 12 o'clock site time in 32ish hours from this post.

In your diary rooms post Who did this, When they did it, and as far as your can work out How they did it.

Points will be given for each part you get right, however for each part you get wrong, or fail to answer the killer will instead gain points. grumpy

[BigSam]

Just to clarify, for the how, to get maximum points, tell us how the killer entered and left the room without being seen, and any extra information which you can discover. grumpy

[Deleted]

Hm, seems to me whoever's the murderer gets the most points in the end.

Jul 31, 2014 16:02:33 GMT @tryinadaendels said:

Jul 28, 2014 15:05:57 GMT Big Anka said:

Dreams: You investigate the dreamatorium log, it turns out Hermes was dreaming up the next chapter in a collaborative fiction, but now it will never be finished.

Heh heh grumpy

[Deleted]

So! The brillant detective I am, I've prepared several maps with all BB residents and their walking lines throughout the day of the murder, according to the collected statements. You're welcome guys, thank me by not voting for my eviction.

Day of the Murder according to my statements.

Day of the Murder according to my statements and Pen's.

Day of the Murder according to my statements, Pen's, & Betsy's.

Day of the Murder according to my statements, Pen's, Betsy's, & MisterM's.
MrM's statements only affect Hours 4 and 9.

Day of the Murder according to my statements, Pen's, Betsy's, MisterM's, & Bandit's.

Day of the Murder according to my statements, Pen's, Betsy's, MisterM's, Bandit's, & Pandora's.
Pandora's statements only affect Hours 9 and 10.

Abbreviations used in the pictures:


And: If a person's (nick)name is in...
...dark blueish: it's according to Pen's statements.
...red: it's according to Betsy's statements.
...grey: it's according to MisterM's statements.
...yellow: it's according to Pandora's statements.
...black: my statements.

Note: The colours of the "walking lines," however, are chosen at random, just so they're visually better separable. If a walking line is dotted, it just means that it's according to someone else than me, but I think I've been slightly inconsistent with that, so you could choose to ignore whether a line is dotted or not.


INCONSISTENCIES among the statements:

Jul 30, 2014 22:01:28 GMT Rellim said:

At Hour 3 You remain at the bar, Terry joins you but Pandora leaves to go inside. Pen also goes inside.

A-ha! Terry does in fact not join you at the cocktail bar!

Jul 30, 2014 22:14:53 GMT @misterm said:

At Hour 3 You get out of the pool and go to the bar, Betsy is still there while pandora has gone inside. Pen is still in the pool.
(...)
At Hour 4 you remain at the bar and Bandit joins you for a drink. Betsy and Pen have gone inside.

A-ha! According to Pen, he is not in the pool by Hour 3 anymore. And during Hour 4 he's going from Bathroom to Living Room! Hmmm...

Jul 31, 2014 0:03:44 GMT @bandit said:

At Hour 4 (...) Pen also sits down in the Living Room coming out from the Bedroom.

A-ha! According to my info, Pen should be coming out of the Bathroom since that's where he went at Hour 3.

While I'm still not sure why Betsy has the wrong info, and everything else with her statement matches with the rest of the statements, I'm gonna give the benefit of the doubt to the Big Brothers' ability to plan out a murder story (sorry). But the evidence I've presented to you here leads me to conclude that Pen is the murderer! It's a result of his whereabouts paired with the evidence collected in this thread and the incongruousness in the statements all coming from him.

I have a theory as to how, but that is for everyone to figure out for themselves; I ain't sharing my points if I don't have to! grumpy

[Rellim]

Damn Terry, you should use your apparently ample free time and draw me pictures and write me songs instead of diagram color-coordinated alibi inconsistencies.

[Deleted]

I know, I know, I just thought I needed to invest some time after being away for some days to continue staying on board. But I'm glad to tell you that otherwise I'm using my time really very well grumpy

[Pen]

aaactually, you're wrong and probably just gave the actual murderer a bunch of points. I have no way to prove it, but you'll find out soon enough. grumpy

[BigSam]

That's some awesome detective work. But instead of noting where people moved, try noting where people spent the rest of each hour.

(Sorry trying not to meddle but you've put some awesome work in there so I'm giving you a nudge. ) grumpy

[BigSam]

I'll do some double checking of other information when I'm home from work. grumpy